- Open Access
Detecting treeline dynamics in response to climate warming using forest stand maps and Landsat data in a temperate forest
Forest Ecosystems volume 5, Article number: 23 (2018)
Treeline dynamics have inevitable impacts on the forest treeline structure and composition. The present research sought to estimate treeline movement and structural shifts in response to recent warming in Cehennemdere, Turkey. After implementing an atmospheric correction, the geo-shifting of images was performed to match images together for a per pixel trend analysis. We developed a new approach based on the NDVI, LST (land surface temperature) data, air temperature data, and forest stand maps for a 43-year period. The forest treeline border was mapped on the forest stand maps for 1970, 1992, 2002, and 2013 to identify shifts in the treeline altitudes, and then profile statistics were calculated for each period. Twenty sample plots (10 × 10 pixels) were selected to estimate the NDVI and LST shifts across the forest timberline using per-pixel trend analysis and non-parametric Spearman’s correlation analysis. In addition, the spatial and temporal shifts in treeline tree species were computed within the selected plots for four time periods on the forest stand maps to determine the pioneer tree species.
A statistically significant increasing trend in all climate variables was observed, with the highest slope in the monthly average mean July temperature (tau = 0.62, ρ < 0.00). The resultant forest stand maps showed a geographical expansion of the treeline in both the highest altitudes (22 m–45 m) and the lowest altitudes (20 m–105 m) from 1970 to 2013. The per pixel trend analysis indicated an increasing trend in the NDVI and LST values within the selected plots. Moreover, increases in the LST were highly correlated with increases in the NDVI between 1984 and 2017 (r = 0.75, ρ < 0.05). Cedrus libani and Juniperus communis spp. were two pioneer tree species that expanded and grew consistently on open lands, primarily on rocks and soil-covered areas, from 1970 to 2013.
The present study illustrated that forest treeline dynamics and treeline structural changes can be detected using two data sources. Additionally, the results will have a significant contribution to and implication for treeline movement studies and forest landscape change investigations attempting to project climate change impacts on tree species in response to climate warming. The results will assist forest managers in establishing some developmental adaptation strategies for forest treeline ecotones.
Do forest treelines respond to global warming? The vegetation of treelines and alpine ecotones is among the most vulnerable and sensitive to the impact of global warming on earth (Masek 2001, Bharti et al. 2012, Weisberg et al. 2013, Gaire et al. 2017, Mishra and Mainali 2017). The movement of forest treelines towards higher altitudes is mainly related to thermal variations and other factors (Zinnert et al. 2011, Du et al. 2017, Gaire et al. 2017, Holtmeier and Broll 2017, Skowno et al. 2017), such as enhanced atmospheric CO2 and nitrogen deposition (Masek 2001, Grace et al. 2002, Salzer et al. 2009, Capers et al. 2013, Skowno et al. 2017). Simultaneously, increases in these factors usually result in the migration of alpine plants to upper altitudes. Moreover, downward shifts in treelines and decreases in treeline stability have been reported due to harsh environmental conditions (Zhang et al. 2009, Du et al. 2017, Gaire et al. 2017) and human disturbances (Jump and Penuelas 2005, Li et al. 2016b). Indeed, these shifts probably have a remarkable influence on plants that are a carbon sink major source (Hanberry and Hansen 2015, Li et al. 2016a). In fact, the reliable assessment of forest treeline dynamics is essential to conserve the ecological condition of alpine ecotone biodiversity for sustainable management and forest conservation strategies (Grace et al. 2002, Holtmeier and Broll 2010, Mishra and Mainali 2017, Skowno et al. 2017).
Various methods have developed and used in various parts of the world to determine woody plant encroachment in response to global warming, including methods using dendroecological techniques (Danby 2007, Salzer et al. 2009, Du et al. 2017, Gaire et al. 2017, Wang et al. 2017b), aerial photograph assessments (Lutz et al. 2013, Solár 2013, Ropars et al. 2015), field plot resurveys (Grabherr et al. 1994, Holtmeier and Broll 2005, Danby and Hik, 2007a, Elmendorf et al. 2012), satellite images (Masek 2001, Holtmeier and Broll 2005, Fraser et al. 2011, Zinnert et al. 2011, Patrick Shawn Sawyer 2014, Mishra and Mainali 2017, Skowno et al. 2017), repeated photographic evidence (Kullman 1993), palynological data investigations (Grace et al. 2002), seedling recruitment studies (Miller et al. 2017), and model scenarios (Masek 2001, Trivedi et al. 2008). Furthermore, the number of successful investigations that have integrated remote sensing images and historical maps is increasing (Wallentin et al. 2008, Zinnert et al. 2011, Weisberg et al. 2013). Simultaneously, remote sensing data provide both fine- and coarse-resolution data (Fraser et al. 2011, 2012). Moreover, Landsat satellite data are the most effective data sets and cover large areas (Arekhi et al. 2017, Chen et al. 2017). Landsat images, which have been recorded since 1972 and are freely available for a period of more than 45 years with high spatial-temporal resolution and a 16-day revisit time (Masek 2001, Wang et al. 2017a), represent one of the most valuable data sources for determining woody plant encroachment. Likewise, they provide a great resource for depicting timberline dynamics and treeline movements with various methods and vegetation indices (Holtmeier and Broll 2005, 2017, Zinnert et al. 2011, Bharti et al. 2012, Elmendorf et al. 2012, Gaire et al. 2017, Wang et al. 2017a). The NDVI is the most common vegetation index, and it is well known as a good representative of plant biomass. Additionally, the NDVI is directly indicative of plant photosynthetic activity (Zinnert et al. 2011, Du et al. 2016, Li et al. 2016a, Mishra and Mainali 2017). Therefore, monitoring of changes in the NDVI values across the forest timberline border provides a quantitative estimate of the tree biomass and density over time (Singh et al. 2011, Bharti et al. 2012, Sawyer and Stephen 2012, Iverson and McKenzie 2013), which demonstrates trends in historical shifts that can be detected by remote sensing techniques (Singh et al. 2011, Raynolds et al. 2013, Ropars et al. 2015, Morley et al. 2017).
Combining forest stand maps with long-term Landsat data provides a good opportunity for detecting and monitoring historical shifts in the forest structure, timberline border, and treeline movement (Zinnert et al. 2011, Solár 2013). Additionally, another aspect of remote sensing data accessibility is that its data include LST, which provides an unprecedented opportunity to investigate and compare forest dynamics (van Leeuwen et al., 2011) among certain interval times. The importance of LST in climate change analyses has been proven (Cristóbal et al. 2008, Brabyn et al. 2014)(Shuman and Comiso 2002, Parastatidis et al. 2017). However, LST anomalies are poorly investigated, and the spatial and temporal monitoring of LST can be used in treeline monitoring studies. The Mediterranean region is recognized as an area impacted by global warming in Turkey, and it is facing increasing summer temperatures and winter precipitation (Solomon et al. 2007, Talu et al. 2010, Parolly 2015). Moreover, evidence of the upward movement of treelines has been reported in the eastern Karadeniz region (Black Sea), and treelines may move approximately 200–400-m according to climate change predictions (Terzioglu Salih 2015). Some climate change scenarios have indicated that the mountain flora in the western and central Taurus mountain regions (Parolly 2015) and the eastern Mediterranean region are threatened (Ozturk et al. 2015). Conventionally, a treeline vertical movement of approximately 640 m is expected to occur with a 4.5 °C warming rate per century and 33 m of movement per 1 °C increase. Holtmeier and Broll 2017 stated, “82% of coarse scale (regional) variation in treeline elevation is associated with thermal conditions”. However, there is evidence that accelerated glacier melt in sensitive, snow-covered mountain areas due to increasing temperature impacts treeline structure and composition (MacDonald et al. 2008, Capers et al. 2013, Wilmers et al. 2013, Holtmeier and Broll 2017). However, there are a few studies investigating the case of forest treelines in the Mediterranean region, and there is a gap in knowledge about forest treeline dynamics and structural shifts.
The present study objectives were 1) to quantify treeline movement rates from 1970 to 2013 by the combination of NDVI maps with forest stand maps; 2) to explore whether the increasing trends in LST and NDVI coincided with treeline advancement from 1984 to 2017; 3) to determine promising tree species in the timberline border in four times (1970, 1992, 2002, 2013) by overlaying forest stand maps on NDVI maps.
The present research focused on one area in the Mediterranean region, Cehennemdere, which is located in the southern part of Turkey (37.430–38.430° E, 44.650–44.850° N) (Fig. 1). The study area covers 16,413.5 ha, of which 8822 ha were selected as the research area. Investigating the forest management plans of each studied period showed that selected study area was a protected area for wildlife and vegetation gene preservation in all periods. The annual mean temperature is 13.4 °C. Moreover, it is a unique area consisting of various natural vegetation communities, namely, Pinus nigra, Abies cilicica, Juniperus oxycedrus, Quercus sp., Cedrus libani, Juniperus communis spp., Juniperus oxycedrus, and Pinus brutia. The study area indicates the southern boundary of forest in Turkey, which is known as the Taurus Mountains. The study area covers indigenous trees and it receives precipitation at high elevations in the summer months, according to forest management plans (OGM, 2016).
Landsat data preparation and other data collection
Landsat data were acquired from ESA (European Space Agency) (http://www.esa.int/ESA). These data have a medium, 30 m spatial resolution. The 1972 Landsat MSS was considered a base map for determining the forest treeline in 1984. Concurrently, images were acquired from 1984 to 2017, except for 2012 (29 Landsat 5 TM and four Landsat 8 OLI images). However, on both the ESA and USGS websites, Landsat data for the maximum growing season were not available from 1972 to 1983. Typically, phonological differences are another major factor impacting the digital number of images. For this reason, the maximum growing season was chosen to reduce the influence of some errors (Fraser et al. 2011). In addition, Bing Aerial data with a high spatial resolution, which were taken in 2017, were used to monitor the current status of the forest timberline and treeline. The atmospheric correction of all scenes was performed using the Dark Object Subtraction 1 approach (Chavez and others 1996, Congedo 2016). In addition, all images had been orthorectified by the provider, and all preprocessing processes, including checking cloud impacts, were performed. Further, Landsat 8 OLI images were considered base images, and other images were geo-shifted by the “geoshift” function of the “Landsat” package. It is valuable to note that applying this function on images significantly reduces the impacts of geo-registration errors by warping images (Masek 2001) using georeferencing images. The NDVI maps were calculated for the study period. The LST maps were generated using statistical algorithms in three steps by considering both the NDVI and the thermal bands (Weng et al. 2004). At the same time, all images were subset to the research area. First, we derived the mean LST for each year from 1984 to 2017 to estimate the significance of the LST change trend over the study period for the entire study area. Second, 20 experimental sites (10 × 10 pixel) across the treeline ecotone boundaries were selected using the stratified random method. To illustrate, multiple plots were selected to track the forest stand shifts across the forest–alpine ecotone edges throughout the research area. Simultaneously, the established plots of mean NDVI and LST were calculated separately for each sample plot five times (1984–1992–2002-2013-2017). In addition, each plot pixels’ center was determined by the “pixel centroid” function to perform a pixel-based trend analysis for the nine time periods (1984–1988–1992-1997-2002-2007-2010-2013-2017). In addition, the forest stand maps were acquired from the General Directorate of Forestry four times (1970–1992–2002-2013). The forest stand maps were prepared using photointerpretation techniques with 1/15000 scale aerial photographs and field-based survey measurements. Each forest stand map was georeferenced and digitized by importing in the Qgis environment. Simultaneously, to display the treeline, a vector layer of the study area territory was prepared by digitizing the forest stand map. At the same time, we determined the forest treeline for each period from the available forest stand maps by digitizing the highest trees species stands on the topography map (1970–1992–2002-2013) using the “Profile tool” plugin. This plugin plots terrain profiles along interactive polylines based on the DEM with 30 m spatial resolution. Then, profile statistics were calculated through the “qProf” plugin for each treeline border elevation. Annual monthly air temperature (mean, min, max) data were obtained for 1970–2017 from the Mersin meteorological station of the Turkish State Meteorological Service. It is important to highlight that the interpolation analysis was not performed to extract the temperature grid maps due to the lack of sufficient meteorological stations within the study area. All image processing and GIS analyses were conducted with the “semi-automatic classification” plugin of Quantum GIS (QGIS Development 2015) (QGIS Development Team 2015). The methodological flow chart shows the method step by step (Fig. 2). In the present study we tried to develop a new method using remote sensing, air temperature data, and forest stand maps to depict treeline dynamics for over more than 43 years. First, Mann-Kendall trend test is used to investigate significance trend the all temperature variables. Second, the forest treeline border was mapped in forest stand maps for each study period (1970, 1992, 2002, and 2013) to identify the treeline altitude, and then the treeline altitude profile statistics for each period were computed. The treeline altitude borders were overlaid on the NDVI maps belonging to each date to detect shifts in the NDVI density. Third, 20 sample plots (10 × 10 pixels) were selected to estimate the NDVI and LST shifts at higher elevations across the timberline for the nine study periods by using per pixel trend analysis. In addition, the spatial and temporal treeline tree species shifts were computed within the selected plots for each period on the forest stand maps to determine the pioneer tree species.
Estimating land surface temperature (LST) maps
The LST maps were estimated in three steps by Landsat thermal bands and NDVI maps using the statistical algorithms applied by Weng et al. 2004; first, the digital numbers of the images were converted to radians values. Second, the image spectral radiance was transformed into satellite brightness temperature. Third, the satellite brightness temperature was converted to land surface temperature. To explain, this process was applied to band 6 for Landsat TM and band 10 for Landsat 8 OLI. The LST map was generated for each study period in °C. Moreover, this method considers both NDVI and thermal bands to calculate the LST (Weng et al. 2004). All calculations were done in the Qgis Raster Calculator and R program using the “raster package” and “Landsat package”.
The non-parametric Mann-Kendall trend test and linear model (LM) were implemented to determine variable significances and trends, respectively. In particular, statistical significance was analyzed using the “tua” coefficient. Trend analysis was applied to climate parameters by the Mann-Kendall trend test to identify their trends and the significance of (Fensholt et al. 2012) climate variables (monthly average temperature (TMEAN), monthly average minimum temperature (TMIN), and monthly average maximum temperature (TMAX)). Additionally, profile statistics of the treeline border elevation were computed for each year. To determine treeline shifts from the forest stand maps, the elevational variation was calculated by overlying the stand maps on a topography map for the periods of 1970–1992, 1992–2002, 2002–2013 separately. The obtained treeline maps were overlaid on NDVI maps from the related year to detect any changes in the NDVI density value for each study period at the treeline boundary. The NDVI and LST values of all 20 sampling plots were averaged and recorded in the R environment. At the same time, the normal distribution of LST and NDVI was analyzed using the Shapiro-Wilk test (nonparametric test) for all research periods. Equally, boxplots and scatter plots between the NDVI and LST were separately conducted for each year (1984–1992–2002-2013-2017). The per pixel trends for the NDVI and LST of each sample plot were computed on a pixel-based robust linear model, and the trend significance was calculated for the nine time periods (1984–1988–1992-1997-2002-2007-2010-2013-2017) using the R statistics program. Additionally, the non-parametric Spearman correlation analysis between the per pixel NDVI and LST was estimated between 1984 and 2017. Concurrently, spatial and temporal tree species changes were computed within the selected plots to monitor forest stand structure and treeline shifts for four time periods (1970–1992–2002-2013). Moreover, the significance levels were set at four values (0.00, 0.001, 0.01, 0.05). All statistical analyses were performed with R software (TEAM and others 2010) and various Quantum GIS (QGIS Development 2015) plugins.
Time series Mann-Kendall trend analysis
A statistically significant and increasing trend in all climate variables was observed (Fig. 3). The time series analysis of temperature data, mainly the monthly average temperature, indicated the study area encountered a prominent warming trend of at least 3 °C since 1980 (Table 1) and it warmed by 4 °C since 1970. The trend analysis of the long-term mean LST (tau = 0.265, ρ< 0.01), monthly average mean temperature (TMEAN), monthly average minimum temperature (TMAX), and monthly average maximum temperature (TMAX) displayed statistically a positive trend over the study period (Table 1). An analysis of the average monthly mean and maximum air temperature over 32 years (from 1984 to 2016) revealed most significant warming trend in July ((tau = 0.62, ρ< 0.00 for TMEAN7), (tau = 0.595, ρ< 0.00 for TMAX7)), January – July ((tau = 0.525, ρ< 0.00 for TMEAN1–7), (tau = 0.523, ρ< 0.00 for TMAX1–7)), and January – December ((tau = 0.562, ρ< 0.00 for TMEAN12), (tau = 0.558, ρ< 0.00 for TMAX12)), respectively (Table 1).
Elevational Treeline change
The treeline altitudinal position and its change were explored for the 1970–1992, 1992–2002, and 2002–2013 periods. Treeline shifts in both the lowest and highest treeline altitudes occurred in all three time periods (Table 2). The highest treeline altitude reached 2442.48 m in 2013, while it was 2335 m in 1970. The 1992–2002 period experienced a treeline rise of approximately 44.45 m, which was much greater than those of other periods. The lowest treeline altitude increased by nearly 22.3 m between 2002 and 2013. In addition, the estimated lowest treeline altitude increased from 1158.75 m in 1970 to 1303.82 m in 2013 (Table 2). Similarly, the comparison of stands at the time periods revealed that the timberline density and treeline increased notably from 1970 to 2013 in the forest stand maps (Fig. 4). Notwithstanding, the observed shifts were not consistent across the entirety of the forest stand boundaries. No prominent shifts were detected in some upmost stands. However, according to the spatial distribution details of the forest stand maps, there is evidence for the expansion of forest tree species in all parts of the study area, indicating treeline advancement towards higher elevations. In total, tree species patches have increased over the study period according to the documented forest stand maps, and this trend was obviously observed on the Bing Aerial images in the Qgis environment. At the same time, the visual interpretation of the NDVI maps by Bing Aerial images indicated an obvious increase across the forest stand border (Fig. 4).
Sample plot analysis
The NDVI and LST values of sample plots have increased from 1984 to 2017. Significant increases in the mean NDVI and LST range values within the sample plots were estimated for each study period (1984–1992- 2002-2013-2017) (Fig. 5a). The magnitude of the average NDVI shift was positive and statistically meaningful. The rise in NDVI was positively correlated with the increasing average LST (Table 4) for each study period for both the mean and minimum LST parameters but not the maximum LST parameter. A moderate positive correlation between the mean NDVI and mean LST at most sample plots in the entire study period (1984, 1992, 2013, 2017) was observed, except for in 2002. There was a statistically significant positive correlation between the mean NDVI and the mean LST (r = 0.634; ρ< 0.05) in 1984 (Table 3). The boxplots demonstrate a consistent increase in the mean NDVI values at the sample plots of the forest edges (Fig. 5a). Concurrently, these event coincide with the increases in LST at the sample plots (Fig. 5b). The LST range varied from 24 °C to 38 °C over the study period (Fig. 5b). The mean LST and NDVI values demonstrated an increasing trend over time, with R2 values of R2 = 0.94 and R2 = 0.96, respectively (Fig. 6). Each NDVI and LST pixel showed an increasing trend over time based on the per pixel analysis (1984–1988–1992-1997-2002-2007-2010-2013-2017). The correlation analysis of the mean NDVI with the mean LST indicated a significantly positive correlation (r = 0.75, ρ< 0.05). The per-pixel correlation coefficient between NDVI and LST varied (r = 0.22–0.99). The mean NDVI increased from 0.25 to 0.39 from 1984 to 2017 at the 20 sample plots (Fig. 7). The mean NDVI density at each site varied among study periods. The NDVI greenness trend result was consistent with the forest tree species cover. In plots 1, 2, 3, 7, 13, 15, 17, and 18, the rock and soil cover extent consistently decreased and was replaced by sparse Juniperus communis spp. and Cedrus libani. Tree developmental stage, tree crown closure, and tree diameter increased gradually from 1970 to 2017 in plots 4, 5, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 14, 19, and 20. The monitoring of plot 16 showed there was a consistency between the rising NDVI trend and the extent of the classes (Fig. 6 and Fig. 8). However, each site consisted of the tree species (mostly Cedrus libani, Juniperus communis spp.), soil, and rock classes. In general, the tree species increased from 1970 to 2013. In all observed sites, the species Cedrus libani consistently rose more than the other tree species over the study period. However, an exploration of the forest stand sample plots revealed that the gradual upward movement of Cedrus libani over the study period coincided with that of Juniperus communis spp. from 1970 to 2013. At the same time, NDVI density was accompanied with an increasing trend of forest stand greening. Moreover, an examination of the composition and structure of each sample plot showed the complexity and diameter of the older tree species increased (Fig. 7). All sample plots had an overall reduction in the rock class from 1970 to 2013 (Fig. 8). Cedrus libani and Juniperus communis spp. were two tree species that increased rapidly from 1970 to 2013. An expansion in Cedrus libani on the rocks was observed in the forest stand maps (Fig. 8), mostly in the sparse form. However, Quercus sp., Pinus brutia and Pinus nigra were three tree species that disappeared in the 2013 forest stand map, while they were present in the 1970 forest stand maps (Fig. 8).
This paper reports the feasibility of detecting treeline dynamics and structural shifts through the integration of Landsat data with forest stand maps. Additionally, the present study sets aimed to address the importance of measured forest stand maps at certain time intervals in forest treeline dynamics investigations, which has been less considered by prior studies. The current study found that the treeline expanded from 1970 to 2013 according to the performed difference analysis between the time periods. The resultant maps showed the geographical expansion of the uppermost treeline over 43 years, with an expansion of approximately 20 to 40 m each decade; the treeline altitude increased to 2442.5 m from 2335 m (Table 2). However, changes in some regions were not uniform (Virtanen et al. 2010, Elmendorf et al. 2012, Hanberry and Hansen 2015, Bruggeman et al. 2016). The findings of the current study are consistent with those of previously conducted investigations that have either used remote sensing data or field survey data, such as tree species dendrological measurements (Danby and Hik, 2007a, Du et al. 2017), alpine ecotone biology observations (Virtanen et al. 2010), repeated photo evidence (Grace et al. 2002, Fraser et al. 2011), and remote sensing method (Masek 2001, Grace et al. 2002, Fraser et al. 2012, Li et al. 2016b, Holtmeier and Broll 2017). Moreover, the movement of the treeline to higher elevations has been reported as a response to global warming, mainly the increase in air temperature. The trend analysis of monthly average temperature (TMIN, TMAX, TMEAN) displayed a statistically positive trend over the study period, especially in the monthly average mean July temperature (tau = 0.62, ρ< 0.00) (Table 1). As discussed, our research supports that climate warming is accompanied by the advancement of treelines towards higher elevations (Danby 2007, Virtanen et al. 2010, Singh et al. 2011, Monleon and Lintz 2015, Du et al. 2017). Our study findings are consistent with those of other scientific studies that have recorded the upslope movement of trees, particularly those in the northern hemisphere (MacDonald et al. 2008, Solár 2013). Similar results achieved by other investigations have emphasized the potential of recorded historical Landsat data to provide an extraordinary opportunity for observing and determining forest timberline and treeline shifts (Masek 2001, Weisberg et al. 2013). Previous studies have suggested and documented an altitudinal advance of the treeline worldwide between 140 and 700 m over the past century (Grace et al. 2002), with an average change of 3 m per year (Singh et al. 2011). Moreover, for some cases, a mean altitudinal change for tree species of nearly 29 m has been reported. A 1 °C increase in temperature leads to 11–40 m of treeline expansion (Grabherr et al. 1994, Lenoir et al. 2008). Similarly, our finding depicted a 4 °C increase over 40 years, which confirmed the treeline increased between 20 to 40 m per decade, if we assume that temperature increased 1 °C per decade. In other findings, the expansion rate of the lowest treeline altitude was between 20 m to 106 m, which needs to be investigated in further studies (Table 2). In addition, numerous investigations have reported that the upward trend in treeline movement is likely to result in the natural succession of trees and reach an optimum in the Early Holocene, which must be considered in further investigations (Grace et al. 2002, MacDonald et al. 2008, Holtmeier and Broll 2010). These shifts would have a significant impact on the landscape, affecting the plants, microorganisms, and animals that live in the tangible mountain ecosystem. Additionally, if the upward expansion of trees continues, they will reduce high-latitude albedo and increase global warming (MacDonald et al. 2008). Therefore, they are possibly contributing to further climate warming (Liess et al. 2012).
The selected plots showed an increasing trend in the mean NDVI and LST values over the study period. However, the results indicate that the increase in the mean NDVI was consistent with the increase in the mean LST (Fig. 5a). A moderately positive correlation between the mean NDVI and mean LST values at most sample plots in all study periods for each year (1984, 1992, 2013, 2017) was observed, except for in 2002. There was a statistically significant positive correlation between the mean NDVI and the mean LST (r = 0.634; ρ< 0.05) in 1984 (Table 3). The increasing trends in mean LST and NDVI had R2 values of R2 = 0.94 and R2 = 0.96, respectively (Fig. 6). The increase in the mean NDVI was positively correlated with the increase in the mean LST using per pixel correlation analysis in the nine time periods between 1984 and 2017 (r = 0.75, ρ< 0.05) (1984–1988–1992-1997-2002-2007-2010-2013-2017). The correlation coefficient was positive and significant (r = 0.901–0.777, ρ< 0.05) between the forest stand density and summer temperature in (Danby and HIK, 2007b) the study, with values of r = 0.537, ρ< 0.05 (Li et al. 2016b). Based on the field investigations, a significant and positive trend and meaningful correlation was observed between the temperature and tree growth in July (Körner 1998, Li et al. 2016b), which is in agreement with the results obtained for the 20 sample plots and July LST temperature over the study period using per pixel trend analysis (r = 0.75, ρ< 0.05). Therefore, according to per pixel trend analysis, the increasing LST played a considerable role in the increasing NDVI trend during the study period in the selected plots (Fig. 6). The warmer the pixel temperature, the higher the tree species growth and seedlings (MacDonald et al. 2008, Monleon and Lintz 2015, Miller et al. 2017). This finding suggests that the tree expansion in the study area can be attributed to climate change factors, especially temperature (Fraser et al. 2011). The monthly average temperature in July was the variable that experienced the largest significant shift among the climate factors in our study (tau = 0.62, ρ< 0.00) (Table 1). The control of the treeline situation by the summer temperature (Harsch et al. 2009), mostly the mean July temperature, has been proven in Northern Eurasia (MacDonald et al. 2008). The monitoring of treelines has delineated that altitudinal forest expansion is evident in all of the study sites, with a consistent warming trend (Liess et al. 2012, Morton et al. 2012, Hanberry and Hansen 2015) in the LST values from 1984 to 2017. Concurrently, it seems that the temperature increases possibly met the growth needs of tree species (Grace et al. 2002). However, year-to-year changes in climate factors, mainly temperature, can be anticipated to have a significant influence on vegetation shifts (Virtanen et al. 2010). In previous studies, it has been noted that rising temperature is the main reason for shifts in the timberline ecotone. It is likely that the expansion of temperate forests reflects increases in temperature as an indicator of global warming (Salzer et al. 2009, Singh et al. 2011, Hanberry and Hansen 2015).
There is obviously mounting evidence of shifting landscape structures at the sample plots (Fig. 8). In the research area, during the last three decades, Cedrus libani and Juniper communis spp. have moved to higher elevations in all directions more quickly than other coniferous species, according to the comparison of the available forest stand maps for each decade (Fig. 8). These shifts can be considered increasing greenness in the resultant NDVI maps (Fig. 4). However, in some stands, shifts in the observed tree species cannot be distinguished by the NDVI values. An examination of 20 sample plots showed a consistent increase in the NDVI greening trend and vascular plants, especially Juniper communis spp. and Cedrus libani. Moreover, the expansion of Juniper spp. into grassland was reported by multitemporal analysis of vegetation indices extracted from Landsat data (Wang et al. 2017a). In addition, the expansion of forest into treeless regions was recorded (Wallentin et al. 2008). Similar to the increasing NDVI trends in the sample plots, findings showed that the forest stand tree species covers expanded, especially in sample plots with already enduring tree species stands (MacDonald et al. 2008, Fraser et al. 2011, Solár 2013, Ropars et al. 2015), mostly based on the NDVI obtained using Landsat data (Bharti et al. 2012, Morton et al. 2012, Fraser et al. 2014, Patrick Shawn Sawyer 2014). Interestingly, according to previously conducted investigations, Cedrus libani is a promising tree species that is able to sustain even the severe cold of winter and extended summer droughts. In addition, Cedrus libani depicted a high compatibility with climate change conditions, and it is likely to provide permanent and productive forest stands (Hajar et al. 2010, Güney et al. 2015, Messinger et al. 2015). Furthermore, the expansion of Cedrus libani to higher elevations was recorded by the model scenario investigations, and its adaptation is discussed (Hajar et al. 2010). Various tree species responded differently, which needs to be considered in further studies. Another important finding is the expansion of Cedrus libani on the rocks more than Juniperus communis spp. according to forest stand maps. Three tree species (Quercus sp., Pinus brutia and Pinus nigra) were replaced with Juniper communis spp. and Cedrus libani (Fig. 8). The expansion of woody species has been reported at a global scale (Zinnert et al. 2011). The present research proved that it is possible to detect and estimate the compositional and structural shifts in tree species types under climatic warming using forest stand maps, and our findings are consistent with those of previous scientific studies conducted at the treeline ecotone (Virtanen et al. 2010, Singh et al. 2011). However, it cannot be denied that the response of each tree species to warming varies, which is likely related to their particular ecological characteristics and basic requirements and the site states. However, high mountains in the eastern Mediterranean are seriously affected by climate warming, so the effects of anthropogenic impacts and forest fires (Ozturk et al. 2015) need to be investigated in further studies. Both data sets complement each other and add a reality and validity to the obtained results. This significant aspect is discussed in other studies (Fraser et al. 2011, Iverson and McKenzie 2013). It should be noted that the available forest stand maps which is generate with high accuracy (Cakir 2006, Ozkan and Yesil 2016) or repeated field survey measurements validate the NDVI greenness obtained from remote sensing data for vegetation cover (Fraser et al. 2011) and high aerial photos, such as Bing Aerial maps. Integrating other ecological factors, dendrological studies and tree species seedling recruitment and putting experimental plots in the study area are suggested. In further investigations, treeline sensitivity to shifts in environmental parameters should be considered in various forest types, such as the tropical and boreal forest. Furthermore, the importance of treeline history needs to be considered in treeline dynamics studies. It has been emphasized, considering the post-glacial history of the research area, that impacts on treeline position shift the existing ecotone structure (Fraser et al. 2014, Holtmeier and Broll 2017). However, the research area has experienced a rapid warming, and its glaciers disappeared in 1980 (Yavasl횤 et al. 2015). If the upward movement of the treeline continues, it is likely to threaten the biodiversity of the plant belts in the higher altitudes. It should be noted that the present study has its limitations. One of its weaknesses is the lack of enough meteorological stations in the study area. According to the obtained results, one alternative to meteorological stations is the use of LST maps with Landsat thermal bands, which provide temperature information for each 30 m × 30 m pixel. However, many studies have proved the feasibility of using LST instead of air temperature in remote regions (Shuman and Comiso 2002, Cristóbal et al. 2008, Brabyn et al. 2014). Moreover, the LST potential in climate change investigations has been reported in forest monitoring studies (Shuman and Comiso 2002, Parastatidis et al. 2017).
The present research illustrates the feasibility of monitoring treeline expansion rates and structural shifts using forest stand maps, long-term Landsat data (NDVI, LST), and temperature data for more than 43 years. The results were verified by available high-resolution Bing Aerial images in the Qgis environment and existing forest stand maps. The uncertainties associated with the use of only Landsat data or forest stand maps are likely reduced by integrating two datasets with Bing Aerial maps based on the applied method. In the present study, three significant sciences, namely, GIS techniques, remote sensing data, and field-based measurements, were integrated. Prior studies have been conducted based on just remote sensing and greenness or just field-based methods (dendrology and biology studies). This study showed that LST, an indicator of temperature, and NDVI, a surrogate of the green biomass of the treeline ecotone, demonstrated an overall increasing trend from 1983 to 2017 at the plot scale. The research results show that treeline temperature anomalies can be detected successfully in the ecotone zones with LST by using per pixel trend analysis and linear model. Additionally, shifts in the heterogeneity of the forest structure over space and time can be detected by integrating two data sources. Moreover, the present study depicted an apparent change and increase in both Cedrus libani and Juniperus communis spp. and determined two pioneer tree species by both NDVI maps and forest stand maps. In the current study, Cedrus libani became a pioneer tree with Juniperus communis spp. the results showed that warmer temperatures enhanced the NDVI values, which supports the hypothesis that climate warming leads to the upward movements of treelines. Therefore, determining how the timberline border vegetation responds to increasing temperatures helps establish some developmental adaptation strategies for forest managers in the treeline ecotone. Future investigations should focus on the comparison of NDVI and other vegetation indices to examine their performance in detecting timberline and treeline movements. Further studies should investigate the expansion and reduction in various tree species, such as Cedrus libani, and Juniperus communis spp., and their competition and compromises with other tree species. Additionally, investigating other alpine vegetation shifts, such as shifts in shrubs and herbs, is recommended. These findings suggest that, in general, these outputs can be used effectively in niche modeling studies, although tree species modeling scenario investigations are based on stimulation rather than experimental data. In addition, future research should examine the contributions of other factors on timberline and treeline movement dynamics. Moreover, the use of medium-resolution data, namely, ESA’s Sentinel 2A and radar remote sensing data, that provide more reliable information coinciding with optical remote sensing data is recommended.
Land Surface Temperature
- MEAN, MAX, MIN:
Mean, maximum, minimum
Average January – July temperature
Average January – December temperature
Normalized Difference Vegetation Index
Monthly average maximum temperature
Monthly average temperature
- TMEAN7, TMAX7, TMIN7:
July mean temperature, July maximum temperature, July minimum temperature
Monthly average minimum temperature
Average July temperature
Arekhi M, Y횤lmaz OY, Y횤lmaz H, Akyüz YF (2017) Can tree species diversity be assessed with Landsat data in a temperate forest? Environ Monit Assess 189:586
Bharti RR, Adhikari BS, Rawat GS (2012) Assessing vegetation changes in timberline ecotone of Nanda Devi National Park, Uttarakhand. Int J Appl Earth Obs Geoinf 18:472–479
Brabyn L, Zawar-Reza P, Stichbury G, Cary C, Storey B, Laughlin DC, Katurji M (2014) Accuracy assessment of land surface temperature retrievals from Landsat 7 ETM+ in the dry valleys of Antarctica using iButton temperature loggers and weather station data. Environ Monit Assess 186:2619–2628
Bruggeman D, Meyfroidt P, Lambin EF (2016) Forest cover changes in Bhutan: revisiting the forest transition. Appl Geogr 67:49–66
Cakir, G. 2006. Orman Amenajman Planlamasinda Gerekli Bilisimin Saglanmasi icin Uzaktan Algilama ve Cografi Bilgi Sistemlerinden Yararlanilmasi. Doktora Tezi, KTU. Fen Bilimleri Enstitusu, Trabzon
Capers, R. S., K. D. Kimball, K. P. McFarland, M. T. Jones, A. H. Lloyd, J. S. Munroe, G. Fortin, C. Mattrick, J. Goren, D. D. Sperduto, and others. 2013. Establishing alpine research priorities in northeastern North America. Northeast Nat 20:559–577
Chavez, P. S., and others. 1996. Image-based atmospheric corrections-revisited and improved. Photogramm Eng Remote Sens 62:1025–1035
Chen, B., X. Xiao, X. Li, L. Pan, R. Doughty, J. Ma, J. Dong, Y. Qin, B. Zhao, Z. Wu, and others. 2017. A mangrove forest map of China in 2015: analysis of time series Landsat 7/8 and sentinel-1A imagery in Google earth engine cloud computing platform. ISPRS J Photogramm Remote Sens 131:104–120
Congedo, L. 2016. Semi-automatic classification plugin documentation: release 5.0. 2.1. https://doi.org/10.13140/RG%202:1
Cristóbal J, Ninyerola M, Pons X (2008) Modeling air temperature through a combination of remote sensing and GIS data. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres 113:1–13.
Danby, R. K. 2007. Alpine treeline and climate warming: a multiscale study of pattern and process in Southwest Yukon. ProQuest
Danby RK, Hik DS (2007a) Variability, contingency and rapid change in recent subarctic alpine tree line dynamics. J Ecol 95:352–363
Danby RK, HIK DS (2007b) Responses of white spruce (Picea glauca) to experimental warming at a subarctic alpine treeline. Glob Chang Biol 13:437–451
Du H, Liu J, Li M-H, Büntgen U, Yang Y, Wang L, Wu Z, He HS (2017) Warming-induced upward migration of the alpine treeline in the Changbai Mountains, Northeast China. Glob Chang Biol
Du J, Zhao C, Shu J, Jiaerheng A, Yuan X, Yin J, Fang S, He P (2016) Spatiotemporal changes of vegetation on the Tibetan plateau and relationship to climatic variables during multiyear periods from 1982–2012. Environmental Earth Sciences 75:77
Elmendorf, S. C., G. H. Henry, R. D. Hollister, R. G. Björk, A. D. Bjorkman, T. V. Callaghan, L. S. Collier, E. J. Cooper, J. H. Cornelissen, T. A. Day, and others. 2012. Global assessment of experimental climate warming on tundra vegetation: heterogeneity over space and time. Ecol Lett 15:164–175
Fensholt, R., T. Langanke, K. Rasmussen, A. Reenberg, S. D. Prince, C. Tucker, R. J. Scholes, Q. B. Le, A. Bondeau, R. Eastman, and others. 2012. Greenness in semi-arid areas across the globe 1981–2007—an earth observing satellite based analysis of trends and drivers. Remote Sens Environ 121:144–158
Fraser R, Olthof I, Carrière M, Deschamps A, Pouliot D (2011) Detecting long-term changes to vegetation in northern Canada using the Landsat satellite image archive. Environ Res Lett 6:045502
Fraser R, Olthof I, Carrière M, Deschamps A, Pouliot D (2012) A method for trend-based change analysis in Arctic tundra using the 25-year Landsat archive. Polar Record 48:83–93
Fraser RH, Lantz TC, Olthof I, Kokelj SV, Sims RA (2014) Warming-induced shrub expansion and lichen decline in the western Canadian Arctic. Ecosystems 17:1151–1168
Gaire NP, Koirala M, Bhuju DR, Carrer M (2017) Site-and species-specific treeline responses to climatic variability in eastern Nepal Himalaya. Dendrochronologia 41:44–56
Grabherr G, Gottfried M, Pauli H (1994) Climate effects on mountain plants. Nature 369:448–448
Grace J, Berninger F, Nagy L (2002) Impacts of climate change on the tree line. Ann Bot 90:537–544
Güney A, Kerr D, Sökücü A, Zimmermann R, Küppers M (2015) Cambial activity and xylogenesis in stems of Cedrus libani a. Rich at different altitudes. Botanical studies 56:20
Hajar L, François L, Khater C, Jomaa I, Déqué M, Cheddadi R (2010) Cedrus libani (a. Rich) distribution in Lebanon: past, present and future. Comptes Rendus Biologies 333:622–630
Hanberry BB, Hansen MH (2015) Latitudinal range shifts of tree species in the United States across multi-decadal time scales. Basic and Applied Ecology 16:231–238
Harsch MA, Hulme PE, McGlone MS, Duncan RP (2009) Are treelines advancing? A global meta-analysis of treeline response to climate warming. Ecol Lett 12:1040–1049
Holtmeier F-K, Broll G (2005) Sensitivity and response of northern hemisphere altitudinal and polar treelines to environmental change at landscape and local scales. Glob Ecol Biogeogr 14:395–410
Holtmeier F-K, Broll G (2017) Treelines—approaches at different scales. Sustainability 9:808
Holtmeier K-F, Broll G (2010) Altitudinal and polar treelines in the northern hemisphere causes and response to climate change (Obere und polare Baumgrenze auf der nördlichen Hemisphäre Ursachen und Antwort auf den Klimawandel). Polarforschung 79:139–153
Iverson LR, McKenzie D (2013) Tree-species range shifts in a changing climate: detecting, modeling, assisting. Landsc Ecol 28:879–889
Jump AS, Penuelas J (2005) Running to stand still: adaptation and the response of plants to rapid climate change. Ecol Lett 8:1010–1020
Körner C (1998) A re-assessment of high elevation treeline positions and their explanation. Oecologia 115:445–459
Kullman L (1993) Pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) tree-limit surveillance during recent decades, Central Sweden. Arctic and Alpine Research: 25:1, 24–31
Lenoir J, Gégout J-C, Marquet P, De Ruffray P, Brisse H (2008) A significant upward shift in plant species optimum elevation during the 20th century. Science 320:1768–1771
Li H, Jiang J, Chen B, Li Y, Xu Y, Shen W (2016a) Pattern of NDVI-based vegetation greening along an altitudinal gradient in the eastern Himalayas and its response to global warming. Environ Monit Assess 188:186
Li H, Li Y, Gao Y, Zou C, Yan S, Gao J (2016b) Human impact on vegetation dynamics around Lhasa, southern Tibetan plateau, China. Sustainability 8:1146
Liess S, Snyder PK, Harding KJ (2012) The effects of boreal forest expansion on the summer Arctic frontal zone. Clim Dyn 38:1805–1827
Lutz DA, Powell RL, Silman MR (2013) Four decades of Andean timberline migration and implications for biodiversity loss with climate change. PLoS One 8:e74496
MacDonald G, Kremenetski K, Beilman D (2008) Climate change and the northern Russian treeline zone. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 363:2283–2299
Masek JG (2001) Stability of boreal forest stands during recent climate change: evidence from Landsat satellite imagery. J Biogeogr 28:967–976
Messinger J, Güney A, Zimmermann R, Ganser B, Bachmann M, Remmele S, Aas G (2015) Cedrus libani: a promising tree species for central European forestry facing climate change? Eur J For Res 134:1005–1017
Miller AE, Wilson TL, Sherriff RL, Walton J (2017) Warming drives a front of white spruce establishment near western treeline, Alaska. Global change biology 23(12):5509–5522
Mishra NB, Mainali KP (2017) Greening and browning of the Himalaya: spatial patterns and the role of climatic change and human drivers. Sci Total Environ 587:326–339
Monleon VJ, Lintz HE (2015) Evidence of tree species’ range shifts in a complex landscape. PLoS One 10:e0118069
Morley PJ, Donoghue DN, Chen J-C, Jump AS (2017) Integrating remote sensing and demography for more efficient and effective assessment of changing mountain forest distribution. Ecological Informatics
Morton DC, Masek JG, Wang D, Sexton JO, Nagol JR, Ropars P, Boudreau S, and others. 2012. Satellite-based evidence for shrub and graminoid tundra expansion in northern Quebec from 1986 to 2010. Glob Chang Biol 18:2313–2323
Ozkan UY, Yesil A (2016) Forest stand delineation using Ikonos image and object based image analysis. Journal of the Faculty of Forestry Istanbul University Orman Fakultesi Dergisi 66:600–612
Ozturk M, Hakeem KR, Faridah-Hanum I, Efe R (2015) Climate change impacts on high-altitude ecosystems. Springer, Cham.
Parastatidis D, Mitraka Z, Chrysoulakis N, Abrams M (2017) Online global land surface temperature estimation from Landsat. Remote Sens 9:1208
Parolly G (2015) The high-mountain flora and vegetation of the western and central Taurus Mts. (Turkey) in the times of climate change. In: Climate change impacts on high-altitude ecosystems. Springer, Cham. pp 99–133
Patrick Shawn Sawyer, H. S. 2014. Vegetative response to climate change in the big Pine Creek watershed along a 2,500 meter elevation gradient using Landsat data? Earth Sciences
QGIS Development, T. 2015. Quantum GIS geographic information system. Open Source Geospatial Foundation Project
Raynolds MK, Walker DA, Verbyla D, Munger CA (2013) Patterns of change within a tundra landscape: 22-year Landsat NDVI trends in an area of the northern foothills of the brooks range, Alaska. Arct Antarct Alp Res 45:249–260
Ropars P, Levesque E, Boudreau S (2015) How do climate and topography influence the greening of the forest-tundra ecotone in northern Québec? A dendrochronological analysis of Betula glandulosa. J Ecol 103:679–690
Salzer MW, Hughes MK, Bunn AG, Kipfmueller KF (2009) Recent unprecedented tree-ring growth in bristlecone pine at the highest elevations and possible causes. Proc Natl Acad Sci 106:20348–20353
Sawyer P, Stephen H (2012) Assessing ecological response of the big Pine Creek watershed to climate change using time series analysis of Landsat surface reflectance data over a 28-year period. River Basin Management VII 172:375
Shuman CA, Comiso JC (2002) In situ and satellite surface temperature records in Antarctica. Ann Glaciol 34:113–120
Singh, C., S. Panigrahy, and J. Pariharc. 2011. Alpine vegetation ecotone dynamics in Gangotri catchment using remote sensing techniques. Internaitonal Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences:36–38
Skowno AL, Thompson MW, Hiestermann J, Ripley B, West AG, Bond WJ (2017) Woodland expansion in south African grassy biomes based on satellite observations (1990–2013): general patterns and potential drivers. Glob Chang Biol 23:2358–2369
Solár J (2013) Effect of climate change on mountain pine distribution in western Tatra Mountains. Climate change-realities, impacts over ice cap, sea level and risks. InTech
Solomon, S., D. Qin, M. Manning, Z. Chen, M. Marquis, K. Averyt, M. Tignor, and H. Miller. 2007. IPCC fourth assessment report (AR4). Climate change
Talu, N., M. Özden, S. Özgün, W. Dougherty, and A. Fencl. 2010. Turkey’s National Climate Change Adaptation Strategy and action plan (draft). TR Ministry of Environment and urbanization, General Directorate of Environmental Management, Department of Climate Change, Ankara
TEAM, Rd. C., and others. 2010. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria.. ISBN 3–900051–07–0, URL: http://www.R-project.org
Terzioglu, Salih MK, Tufekcioglu A (2015) Vegetation and plant diversity of high-Altitude Mountains in eastern Karadeniz (Black Sea) region of Turkey and climate change interactions. In: Climate change impacts on high-altitude ecosystems. Spring, pp 383–408
Trivedi MR, Berry PM, Morecroft MD, Dawson TP (2008) Spatial scale affects bioclimate model projections of climate change impacts on mountain plants. Glob Chang Biol 14:1089–1103
van Leeuwen TT, Frank AJ, Jin Y, Smyth P, Goulden ML, van der Werf GR, Randerson JT (2011) Optimal use of land surface temperature data to detect changes in tropical forest cover. Journal of Geophysical Research: Biogeosciences 116:1–16.
Virtanen R, Luoto M, Rämä T, Mikkola K, Hjort J, Grytnes J-A, Birks HJB (2010) Recent vegetation changes at the high-latitude tree line ecotone are controlled by geomorphological disturbance, productivity and diversity. Glob Ecol Biogeogr 19:810–821
Wallentin G, Tappeiner U, Strobl J, Tasser E (2008) Understanding alpine tree line dynamics: an individual-based model. Ecol Model 218:235–246
Wang J, Xiao X, Qin Y, Dong J, Geissler G, Zhang G, Cejda N, Alikhani B, Doughty RB (2017a) Mapping the dynamics of eastern redcedar encroachment into grasslands during 1984–2010 through PALSAR and time series Landsat images. Remote Sens Environ 190:233–246
Wang W, Jia M, Wang G, Zhu W, McDowell NG (2017b) Rapid warming forces contrasting growth trends of subalpine fir (Abies fabri) at higher-and lower-elevations in the eastern Tibetan plateau. For Ecol Manag 402:135–144
Weisberg PJ, Shandra O, Becker ME (2013) Landscape influences on recent timberline shifts in the Carpathian Mountains: abiotic influences modulate effects of land-use change. Arct Antarct Alp Res 45:404–414
Weng Q, Lu D, Schubring J (2004) Estimation of land surface temperature–vegetation abundance relationship for urban heat island studies. Remote Sens Environ 89:467–483
Wilmers CC, Ram K, Watson FG, White P, Smith DW, Levi T (2013) Climate and vegetation phenology. In: Yellowstone’s wildlife in transition. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, pp 147–163
Yavasl횤 DD, Tucker CJ, Melocik KA (2015) Change in the glacier extent in Turkey during the Landsat era. Remote Sens Environ 163:32–41
Zhang Y, Xu M, Adams J, Wang X (2009) Can Landsat imagery detect tree line dynamics? Int J Remote Sens 30:1327–1340
Zinnert JC, Shiflett SA, Vick JK, Young DR (2011) Woody vegetative cover dynamics in response to recent climate change on an Atlantic coast barrier island: a remote sensing approach. Geocarto International 26:595–612
We would like to thank General Directorate of Forestry and Turkish State Meteorological Service which provide forest stand maps and climate data, respectively in our study.
Availability of data and materials
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The authors declare that they have no competing interest.